Skip to main content

If you think Crosby should be suspended, you’re delusional

Sidney Crosby has incited some fiery reactions with a pair of questionable plays this week. His slash on Methot and spear on O’Reilly warranted penalties – but nothing more.

We all feel for Ottawa Senators defenseman Marc Methot. Let’s get that out of the way. The injury he sustained Thursday night after taking a whack on the glove from Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby was gruesome and unfortunate, sure to be mentioned for years to come alongside the horrifying accidents of Clint Malarchuk and Richard Zednik.

If you want to see what happened to Methot’s finger, here’s the video. It’s graphic in nature. You’ve been warned.

An injury that shocking, naturally, invokes a strong reaction. That applies to Ottawa Senators fans, to keyboard warriors on Twitter and even to Senators owner Eugene Melnyk. He spoke on TSN 1200 after it was announced Methot’s finger was shattered and would cost him weeks. Melnyk wanted Crosby to be suspended for the rest of the season since he knocked Methot out long-term.

“We all know who he is, and the guy’s just a whiner beyond belief, and (if) you do this kind of stuff, I don’t care who you are in the league, I don’t care if you’re the No. 1 player in the league,” Melnyk said on the show. "You should sit out a long time for this kind of crap.”

The eye-for-an-eye punishment system isn’t totally foreign. The NHL’s Department of Player Safety does factor injury into suspension sentencing. Sabres defenseman Rasmus Ristolainen, for instance, was a first-time offender but got three games this week for his hit on Pittsburgh’s Jake Guentzel because Guentzel sustained a concussion on the hit.

The league only factors in injury retribution, however, when a play is actually deemed worth suspending. That’s what so many people, especially Melnyk, seem to misunderstand. They’re reacting emotionally to Methot’s injury without considering that what Crosby did was nowhere near worthy of a suspension.

Careless use of the stick, warranting a slashing penalty? Sure. Absolutely. But even Methot’s own defense partner, Erik Karlsson, admitted after Thursday’s game it was a play that happens all the time.

Crosby had no intent to injure Methot. Here’s Methot carrying the puck moments before the slash:


Here’s Crosby winding up his stick while Methot still has possession of the puck. Crosby’s clearly preparing to swing his stick in hopes of separating Methot’s blade from the puck:


Crosby’s stick is too high here to be making a play on the puck, which has some people believing the intent was malicious but, to me, this is Crosby realizing he’s too late to make contact with the puck and instead trying to stop Methot’s follow-through with a stick-on-stick check. Crosby even said as much. Here’s a look:


It should come as no surprise NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly has already stated the league will not take any disciplinary action toward Crosby. He was obviously attempting to make a hockey play, and intent means everything when it comes to supplemental discipline. The windup wasn’t even particularly vicious. Crosby should be much more careful, but that’s about it. Two minutes would’ve sufficed.

And those floating the preposterous theory that the league, the same one that has suspended superstars like Alex Ovechkin three times, is giving Crosby the star treatment have extremely selective memories. That kind of slash happens over and over every game, especially to players like Crosby, who constantly carry the puck and are thus exposed to more checks than most. It happened to Johnny Gaudreau twenty-one times in one game with the Wild this past November, leaving him with a broken finger that required surgery. Here’s a look at his personal house of horrors:

Zero suspensions got handed out. No one should condone slashing by any means, but it’s going to happen. We play and watch a sport that involves sticks. Players have to wear gloves for a reason. If we take issue with anything, it should be the league’s overall treatment of slashing. If officials and the DOPS cracked down harder on all stick infractions, even the unintentional but careless ones, there would be precedent to punish Crosby. But there isn’t. For every one of those he dishes out, he eats half a dozen. It would thus be hypocritical to suspend Crosby.

The same anti-Crosby crowd points to his spearing of Ryan O’Reilly’s groin March 21 as further evidence the league lets No. 87 walk on water. But just because you believe a given play is suspendable doesn’t mean it is, especially with precedent once again factored in. Dirty? Yep. Worthy of a penalty? Yep. But relatively soft contact:

Anyone thinking that would get Crosby suspended is dreaming. This spear by Milan Lucic on Danny DeKeyser in 2014 had considerably more force, with a windup before driving upward:

Lucic’s stick went from the ice to DeKeyser’s cup, and even that only got Lucic slapped with a $5,000 fine. Crosby’s stick was already off the ice when he whacked O’Reilly.

None of this means Crosby is necessarily a clean player. He should’ve been penalized for what he did to Methot and O’Reilly. But the hyperbole has to stop. He doesn’t deserve a season-long suspension. At worst, he deserved a fine for the groin shot. If you’re utterly convinced he’s the second coming of Ulf Samuelsson, a supervillain, then trying to get Crosby banned for these minor, unfortunate incidents is like trying to convict a violent criminal for jaywalking. Save the drama for if and when he does something that really warrants a serious punishment.


Carey Price

Report: Carey Price May Not Play in 2022-23 Season

Montreal Canadiens GM Kent Hughes told reporters that Carey Price may not play at all in the 2022-23 season.

Sean Monahan

Flames Trade Monahan to Canadiens

The Calgary Flames have traded Sean Monahan and a 2025 first-round pick to the Montreal Canadiens in a move to clear cap space.


The Flames Have Turned Heartbreak Into a Shot at Contention

With the signing of Nazem Kadri, the Calgary Flames took what looked to be a devastating offseason and turned it into a chance to become a contender.