Skip to main content

Report: John Scott all-star situation won’t result in changes to fan voting

The All-Star Game in Los Angeles is months away, but fans can start brainstorming about who they want to see in the game this season. The league has decided not to change fan voting even after John Scott’s unexpected captaincy at the 2016 contest.

The NHL isn’t exactly setting the table for John Scott, NHL All-Star: Part Two, but the league doesn’t appear to be all that interested in getting in the way of the fans having their say when it comes to All-Star Game captains.

After the 2016 All-Star Game’s voting was taken over by fans in order to get Scott, he of five goals and 11 career points in 286 games, sent to the mid-season exhibition, there was some belief that the NHL may try to alter voting in time for the 2017 All-Star Game in Los Angeles. However, according to Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman, the league isn’t going to stop fans who want to get behind another write-in candidate.

“It was controversial, to say the least, but it worked out very well for John Scott and the league,” Friedman said of the situation. “It was a great show in Nashville. I think, since then, we’ve all wondered would the league do something about this, would the league change the voting so there couldn’t be another write-in candidate? I’m told there’s going to be no substantive changes to all-star balloting.”

It’s somewhat surprising the league wouldn’t try to regain control of the balloting in some way after Scott’s candidacy caused such an uproar, both positive and negative, but, as Friedman pointed out, Scott’s eventual participation was a huge success and saw fans give tremendous support to the veteran winger. Even though he attended the game without truly representing an NHL team — he appeared in the contest after he was traded away from the Pacific Division’s Arizona Coyotes, whom he was a member of when voted captain — he was named the game’s MVP and was an overwhelming fan favorite.

But even with the option open to fans again, it seems unlikely that there will be a repeat of the Scott situation. There’s no single player who represents quite what Scott did, and, like anything else, there’s no replicating the original feeling or emotion that was tied to the Scott decision.

That said, it does open the door for several players to get a last hurrah on the all-star stage or give some fan favorites an opportunity to have a run as an all-star captain. Veterans such as Jarome Iginla, Shane Doan or Matt Cullen could be playing in their final seasons fit the former category, and the likes of Phil Kessel, Roberto Luongo or even a journeyman such as Lee Stempniak could get a deserving nod when they otherwise might not be heading to the game.

Whoever the write-in candidate is, though, it will be hard to ever match the combination of bizarre online support, ridiculous controversy and fan love that surrounded Scott. That’s likely the reason the league isn’t too concerned about making changes to the fans’ vote. 

And even in the off-chance there’s a Scott-esque captain, there are worse things in the hockey world than a fun storyline heading into a meaningless game.

Want more in-depth features and expert analysis on the game you love? Get 10 issues of The Hockey News magazine for just $15.99!


Mark Giordano

Giordano's Impact Not Ignored by Maple Leafs

Giordano isn’t at the peak he was at when he won the James Norris Trophy in 2019, but his importance to Toronto's blueline – aided by a very cap-friendly deal – is notable for a variety of reasons.

2022 IIHF World Championship

Men's World Championship Roundup: GB, Italy Relegated; Denmark Wins Major Upset

Italy and Great Britain have been relegated from the men's World Hockey Championship, while Denmark pulled off a historic upset over Canada and Czechia shut out USA with one day remaining in round-robin play.


The Lightning are Beating the Panthers at their Own Game

The Florida Panthers won a Presidents' Trophy thanks to their offensive depth. Now, the Tampa Bay Lightning have turned it against them at the worst possible time.