Skip to main content

Shanahan's first task in Toronto: improving Leafs' abysmal draft/development results

Brendan Shanahan is the new president of the Maple Leafs and Adam Proteau says his first priority has to be improving a drafting/development team that – as THN's Future Watch editions prove – is among the NHL's least productive.
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

As Brendan Shanahan settles into his new role as president of the Maple Leafs, he’ll have many issues to examine: the Leafs’ cookie-cutter in-game entertainment, for instance; or the deafening volume of the speakers facing press row. But there’s one topic that ought to take priority over all others – and it’s not the employment status of Toronto’s current coach or GM.

It’s drafting and development, an area in which the Leafs have been woefully lacking for as long as anyone can remember. If anything is going to provide meaningful change in the years to come, it’s better results from their group of talent evaluators and groomers.

If you view Toronto’s draft history/results through the prism of THN’s annual Future Watch edition, the reality becomes all the more painful. Let’s look back over the past decade and see where the Leafs’ collection of prospects have ranked every year. (And remember, each issue's rankings are a result of consultations with a large group of NHL GMs and scouts.)

2005: 24th overall

2006: 24th

2007: 28th

2008: 28th

2009: 29th

2010: 18th

2011: 28th

2012: 20th

2013: 25th

2014: 29th

If you label the 2010 season an anomaly, you can see the Leafs have performed abysmally in building a solid pool of young talent. But wait, there’s more damning evidence: In each edition of Future Watch, the same panel of scouts also determines the top 50 NHL prospects every year. Let’s go year-by-year and determine how many Toronto prospects were in the top 50 (the rank of their top prospect each year will be in parenthesis):

2005: 2 players (top ranked prospect: 33rd overall)

2006: 1 (37th)

2007: 2 (23rd)

2008: 2 (24th)

2009: 0

2010: 3 (13th)

2011: 1 (13th)

2012: 1 (18th)

2013: 1 (19th)

2014: 0

The Leafs hadn’t bulked up their scouting staff until former GM Brian Burke joined the organization in November of 2008 – and while that scouting staff of 23 is now among the largest, if not the largest in the NHL, those results are nothing to take pride in. In fact, given Toronto’s resources, they're absolutely inexcusable.

In fairness, scouting isn’t an exact science. But pro sports aren’t about fairness. They’re about the bottom line, and the Leafs’ bottom line in regard to amateur scouting has been too close to the very bottom for way too long.

If Shanahan can improve Toronto’s drafting and development to the same degree he improved the NHL’s disciplinary office, he’ll have achieved something monumental – and something his predecessors never were able to do.


Ryan Graves and Timo Meier

Should the New Jersey Devils Trade for Sharks' Timo Meier?

The New Jersey Devils are enjoying a breakout season, but they'd benefit from another strong winger. Adam Proteau analyzes a possible trade for Timo Meier.

Pierre-Luc Dubois

Pierre-Luc Dubois Recalls Trade to Winnipeg Two Years Later

Who knows where Pierre-Luc Dubois will be in a year or two? But two years after the trade to the Winnipeg Jets, he's on pace for a career high in points.

Connor Bedard

NHL Sour Rankings: Bedard’s Fit Among the NHL’s Bottom Feeders

How could Connor Bedard fit into each roster of the NHL's current worst teams?