Skip to main content

The 2015 All-Snub All-Star team, featuring P.K. Subban

Which NHLers were unjustly shut out of the 2015 All-Star Game? THN presents an All-Snub All-Star team, complete with which players to cut from the real all-star squad.
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The speediest way to make the entire universe sick to death of the word "snub"? Release the NHL all-star selections and the Oscar nominations in the same week.

P.K. Subban was amazing in Montreal. Loved Jake Gyllenhaal in Nightcrawler. The San Jose Sharks wouldn't be the same team without Joe Thornton, and Cake was nothing without Jennifer Aniston. Snubs. They're all snubs. Snubs, snubs, SNUBS.

My personal favorite way to eliminate a repetitive thought from the brain? Flushing it out. I once listened to What Does the Fox Say? 11 times in a row. Now it's time to build an entire All-Star team consisting of…you guessed it…S-N-U-B-S.

Slicing the existing NHL selections in half, I'll include three goalies, six defensemen and 12 forwards in hopes of deploying them against Team Foligno and Team Toews in an imaginary All-Star round-robin from heaven/hell.

Goaltenders

Marc-Andre Fleury, Penguins*

Jaroslav Halak, Islanders*

Braden Holtby, Capitals

*Fleury and Halak will play in the All-Star Game as injury replacements for Pekka Rinne and Jimmy Howard, but Fleury and Halak were still snubs. I invoke the Martin St-Louis Olympic Sour Grapes rule.

Defensemen

John Carlson, Capitals

Aaron Ekblad, Panthers

Erik Karlsson, Senators

Kris Letang, Penguins

Anton Stralman, Lightning

P.K. Subban, Canadiens

Forwards

Nicklas Backstrom, Capitals

Pavel Datysuk, Red Wings

Marian Hossa, Blackhawks

Filip Forsberg, Predators

Nikita Kucherov, Lightning

Max Pacioretty, Canadiens

Ondrej Palat, Lightning

Joe Pavelski, Sharks

Corey Perry, Ducks

Jaden Schwartz, Blues

Tomas Tatar, Red Wings

Joe Thornton, Sharks

Done. (Dusts off hands).

Wait a second. It's not that easy. Now's the moment readers call me on these so-called snubs. A true snub implies the player deserves to make the all-star team, which implies that player must take another's place. A real all-snub squad requires backing up the choices by cutting the undeserving all-stars. Let's put down the tarp and do that dirty work. Keep in mind I'll choose not to represent all 30 NHL teams. A snub squad will consist of deserving players, regardless of team.

ALL-STAR CUTS

Goaltenders

Corey Crawford, Blackhawks

Crawford has been steady, but he hasn't even looked like the best goalie on his own team, outdone by Antti Raanta.

Defensemen

Justin Faulk, Hurricanes

Brent Seabrook, Blackhawks

Carolina should be thrilled it can build around Faulk, but he's a classic obligatory pick from a bad team. Has he been better than Letang or Subban this year? No way. Seabrook is a rock-solid veteran yin to Duncan Keith's yang, but there's a reason why Keith has two Norrises and Seabrook didn't get an invite to Team Canada last year. Seabrook's great but not elite. I was close to cutting Dustin Byfuglien, as he hasn't spent much of 2014-15 as a defenseman, but he's been too good to ignore.

Forwards

Zemgus Girgensons, Sabres

Patrik Elias, Devils

Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Oilers

Bobby Ryan, Senators

Radim Vrbata, Canucks

Let's move on from Elias to save him any further embarrassment. Girgensons is an exciting young prospect whose play keeps improving – he reminds me of a young Bobby Holik – but that doesn't make him an all-star this year in my mind, leading vote getter or no leading vote getter. Nugent-Hopkins, Vrbata and Ryan have been perfectly decent but are forced choices to ensure 30-team coverage. Guys having superior seasons were snubbed.

With actual cuts out of the way, nine spots open up for a true All-Snub team.

THE ACTUAL 2015 ALL-SNUB ALL-STAR TEAM

Braden Holtby, Capitals

Holtby gets the nod with Fleury and Halak already off to Columbus. It's heartening to see Holtby's save percentage improve every month so far this season. Working with goalie guru Mitch Korn, who followed coach Barry Trotz from Nashville, has been a boon.

Kris Letang, Penguins

It's amazing how overlooked Letang's performance has been. Has he been written off as a one-way player because of some previous defensive deficiencies? On top of being a top-10 scorer in the league at his position, Letang is a solid 17th in Corsi Close among D-men. He also plays more than three minutes a game shorthanded, helping Pittsburgh post the NHL's second best penalty kill at 88.3 percent. He deserves Norris consideration, yet he isn't an all-star? Woof.

P.K. Subban, Canadiens

It's a shame Subban can't attend the All-Star Game for his personality and entertainment value alone. He also happens to be a dominant force on the blueline who does it all. To anyone claiming Seabrook or Faulk deserves a nod over Subban this season, I present the Oh-come-on defense: Oh, come on.

Pavel Datsyuk, Red Wings

The Magic Man has only played 32 games. Who cares? He has a top-10 Corsi Close rating in the NHL, tied with Patrice Bergeron. He hums along at roughly a point per game. He's among the league leaders in faceoff percentage. Datsyuk looks like his vintage self at 36, plus his puck skills are too fun not to showcase at the ASG.

Ondrej Palat, Lightning

Half the Lightning have all-star numbers this season, so they may have split some votes, resulting in Palat's snub. He's one third of arguably the NHL's best line this season and his outstanding defensive play from the wing echoes Jere Lehtinen's.

Joe Pavelski, Sharks

Pavelski has maintained last season's seemingly unsustainable goal-scoring pace. On what planet is a 40-goal man who also kills penalties and cleans up on faceoffs not all-star material? On this planet. Sigh.

Corey Perry, Ducks

Illness and injury have limited Perry to 29 games, and he still has as many goals as all-star captain Nick Foligno. Not earning the fan vote is forgivable since Perry was sidelined for some of the process. But the NHL should've given him some love.

Joe Thornton, Sharks

If you factor in advanced stats, Thornton is enjoying his best all-around campaign since his 100-point early-Shark heyday. His puck protection impacts possession significantly. He's Anze Kopitar, and Kopitar will play in the All-Star Game, so…

Now it's your turn. Share your Snub SNUB teams, presumably captained by Erik Karlsson, in the comments.

Matt Larkin is an associate editor at The Hockey News and a regular contributor to the thn.com Post-To-Post blogFor more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, subscribe to The Hockey News magazineFollow Matt Larkin on Twitter at @THNMattLarkin

TOP HEADLINES

20220119SheldonKeefe
Play

Maple Leafs' Keefe Derides Team's 'Soft and Purposeless' Game Against Rangers

The Toronto Maple Leafs head coach called out his team's play after giving up two-goal lead in a 6-3 loss to the New York Rangers on Wednesday Night.

USATSI_14159321

The War for the NHL's Metro Division is Here

At the beginning of the NHL’s current regular season, there was a good case to be made that the Metropolitan Division was going to be the most difficult of the four divisions. But right now, it looks like four teams will fight for the top spot moving forward.

NHL COVID-19
Play

NHL Announces Massive Schedule Update

The NHL has found new dates for the 98 games that were previously postponed from the past two months due to COVID-19.