Skip to main content

THN.com Blog: Divisional playoff alignment would breed rivalries

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

I suppose when you do anything long enough, you run the risk of breeding blasé.

Nearly 20 years into my career at The Hockey News, however, I can’t ever envision that happening with the NHL playoffs. Every April is a time of renewal and anticipation, knowing there will be stunning upsets, raging refereeing controversies and marathon overtimes. The fun is in watching the thrillers/mysteries unfold.

There is, however, one thing I miss. Perhaps I’m just being wistful, a selective recall kicking in, making a bygone era seem more romantic than it really was, but I’d love to see a return to the divisional playoff format.

Eric Duhatschek weighs in on this in the next issue of The Hockey News and it’s an opinion I’ve shared for a few years: the blood feuds of the 1970s, ’80s and ’90s were the products of repeated post-season meetings and geographical proximity and nearly always seemed epic. The Battles of Alberta and Quebec; Rangers-Islanders; St. Louis-Chicago; Boston-Montreal still resonate.

Granted, with more teams in the league, the frequency of re-matches would diminish, but they’d still occur more often than they do today under a revised system. We’ve lucked into a few, but we could increase the odds by manipulating (and renaming) the divisions into four houses. Here’s how they could look:



Western Conference


Howe Division

Chicago

Colorado

Columbus

Detroit

St. Louis

Minnesota

Nashville

Gretzky Division

Anaheim

Calgary

Dallas

Edmonton

Los Angeles

Phoenix

San Jose

Vancouver

Eastern Conference

Richard Division

Boston

Buffalo

New Jersey

Rangers

Islanders

Montreal

Ottawa

Toronto

Lemieux Division

Atlanta

Carolina

Florida

Philadelphia

Pittsburgh

Tampa

Washington

Top four in each division qualify, with a 1-vs.-4, 2-vs.-3 format. Winners play each other, subsequently moving on to the conference and Stanley Cup final.

If that set-up were employed this season, the first round – based on standings through April 8 – would look this way:

Detroit vs. St. Louis

Chicago vs. Columbus

San Jose vs. Anaheim

Vancouver vs. Calgary

Boston vs. Rangers

New Jersey vs. Montreal

Philadelphia vs. Carolina

Washington vs. Pittsburgh

Six of the eight series’ would be different than under the current system, including a Crosby-Ovechkin showdown, a battle of California, a Detroit-St. Louis old-school matchup and Canadian foes Vancouver and Calgary going head-to-head.

There are downsides, admittedly. Races may not be as tight and a team may qualify ahead of a non-playoff opponent with more points in another division (though that wouldn’t be the case this season), but really, it’s the post-season that matters, isn’t it? If you’re fifth out of seven teams after 82 games…well, you already had your chances.

It may not be perfect, but it’s an idea worth considering if we want to amp things up even further. One of my colleagues even suggested rotating playoff formats every five years, or so, to maintain optimal freshness.

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with leaving things as they are, but if there’s a chance to make a great thing even better, why not consider it?

Jason Kay is the editor in chief of The Hockey News and a regular contributor to THN.com. His blog appears every Friday.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, Subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.

TOP HEADLINES

FTJ5R7vVsAAh8KO

Chloe Primerano Becomes First Woman Skater Drafted to the WHL

Chloe Primerano, a 15-year-old defender from the Burnaby Winter Club U-15 team, has become the first woman skater drafted to the CHL after getting selected 268th overall by the Vancouver Giants.

USATSI_18292373
Play

The Colorado Avalanche Look Ready for the Next Level

Good teams find a way to win, and so far, that's exactly what the Avalanche have done.

2022 IIHF World Championship
Play

Men's World Championship Roundup: Canada, Germany, USA, Czechia Shine

Canada is still perfect, Germany and USA earned shutouts and Czechia bounced back in a big way – and a fire spawned a lot of conversation – during Thursday's World Hockey Championship action in Finland.