Skip to main content Blog: Ranking the playoff goalies

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

As evidenced by the fact 14 Conn Smythe Trophies have gone to the men between the pipes over the years (second only to centers with 15), it’s no secret good goaltending is a key to playoff success.

There’s certainly evidence of teams getting by with crease play that’s just OK, but no collection has ever raised Stanley with a subpar stopper.

This season’s playoffs, more than any other in recent memory, are overflowing with participants who have questions about their keepers. So with that in mind – using regular season play and historical playoff performance as the criteria – let’s run down this year’s 16 starting masked men based on who you’d most want in a seven-game series.


Ryan Miller

Only four career playoff series wins, but put up numbers (40-18-8, 2.23 GAA, .928 SP) that will net him Vezina and maybe Hart honors.


Martin Brodeur

Another underrated regular season; leads the league in shutouts (nine). Most important: How can you argue 98 all-time playoff wins, second in history?


Marc-Andre Fleury

Regular-season resume isn’t nearly as impressive as others’, but his 30 playoff wins – and one Cup ring over the past two years – is far more than anyone not named Osgood, who has 29.


Ilya Bryzgalov

The main reason, beyond Dave Tippett, for Phoenix’s surprise rising in the West. ‘Cool Bryz’ has the tools to win a series on his own. Can you believe he was once on waivers?


Roberto Luongo

Canada’s golden boy has lost his shine in his post-Games play with the Canucks and questions still linger after last year’s Game 6 debacle vs. Chicago, but Louie still stands tall and now has experience.


Tuukka Rask

Benefits from playing behind an ultra-tight system, but has league-leading GAA (1.97) and SP (.931). Tough to put big bet on rookie under playoff pressure, though.


Jaroslav Halak

No playoff wins to his credit, but has been a large part of Montreal’s second-half resurgence. Post-season performance may very well determine whether he or Carey Price is Montreal’s future.


Evgeni Nabokov

Despite great teams in front of him, has only led the Sharks to one conference final in six full tries. Fold-job against Canada in Olympics doesn’t help.


Jimmy Howard

The 26-year-old freshman wrestled the job from Chris Osgood based on impressive play during his first full year, but had a 12-17 American League playoff record with a SP below .900.


Jose Theodore

Numbers are gaudy, especially since the Olympics, but every time I watch a Caps game there’s a soft goal or three that find their way past the former Hart winner.


Pekka Rinne

A common theme on this list, the big Finn was a co-No. 1 until pulling away at mid-season, but hasn’t seen a minute of NHL post-season play. Does possess the tools to steal a game (or maybe a series?) on his own.


Antti Niemi

Another first-year goaltender handed the reins, the flashy Finn doesn’t have to win games for the talented Hawks, he just can’t lose them.


Craig Anderson

Would have been much higher on this list if the playoffs started two months ago, but the Avs have since fallen badly; almost out of the playoffs.


Jonathan Quick

Followed a similar path to Anderson in that a fast start turned into a late struggle. The 24-year-old, with zero NHL post-season experience, has been a workhorse with 71 games-played.


Brian Elliott

Pascal Leclaire was supposed to be the man in the Canadian capital, but the 25-year-old Elliott grabbed the reins with his consistency. Has never played a pro playoff game, though.


Brian Boucher

Only playoff goalie with GAA under .900 and a losing record. Don’t be surprised to see Johan Backlund if he gets healthy.

Edward Fraser is the editor of His blog appears weekly.

For more great profiles, news and views from the world of hockey, subscribe to The Hockey News magazine.

The Hockey News

The Hockey News


Matt Duchene

Matt Duchene Looks To Repeat Last Year's Career-Best Season

While Matt Duchene set career-highs last season, his first NHL team won the Cup. If Nashville wants to improve this year, he must do it again.

Hockey Canada logo

Hockey New Brunswick Withholds Funds From Hockey Canada; Nike pauses support

Hockey New Brunswick joins three other regional hockey bodies in withholding a $3 per player fee from Hockey Canada while Nike pauses its support.


The Top 100 NCAA Players to Get Excited About for 2022-23

Our annual list of the most intriguing names in men's hockey is here, with plenty of national championship hopefuls and NHL prospects.