Skip to main content

Why it will take time before McDavid, Eichel make serious impact

If history is to be believed, the Edmonton Oilers and Buffalo Sabres should temper their expectations for the 2015-16 season. Even with generational talents in Connor McDavid and Jack Eichel, it’s bound to take some time before either rookie makes a big impact on the fate of their NHL club.
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The Edmonton Oilers and Buffalo Sabres have made it very clear – it’s time to flip the switch. The two franchises collected their rewards for a season of ineptitude – two generational talents in

Connor McDavid and

Jack Eichel – 12 days ago at the draft and they’ve been bathing in optimism ever since with an attitude that suggests they’re going to waste no time in getting the teams back into contention. The two teams made some of the biggest moves during the off-season that show they mean just that. Edmonton traded for goaltender

Cam Talbot and added steady defender

Andrej Sekera during free agency, while Buffalo got a young, almost-elite center in

Ryan O’Reilly to go with their own new goaltender,

Robin Lehner. They’re very good moves for both clubs and there’s no doubt that the teams are much better because of it. Here’s the thing: these two teams were already very bad. In terms of goal difference, Buffalo allowed 113 more goals than they scored while Edmonton allowed 85. Not many teams have put up numbers that atrocious (adjusted to this year’s goal-scoring levels and talent distribution) since the league has expanded and those that have were still pretty bad the next season, too.

On average, the 33 teams that had an adjusted goal difference below -80 improved by 45 goals the next season, which is about 15 points in the standings. That would still leave Edmonton and Buffalo below 80 points. And while almost one of every five teams made the playoffs the next year, only one of 14 has made it since the league expanded to 30 teams. Basically, both these teams are in tough. But perhaps these two teams will be exceptions to the rule, they did add a lot of talent after all, and it’s possible to project just how much using wins above replacement from The method is the same as our free agency post where we used a player’s last three seasons to get an estimate of what he’ll do next season with consideration to his age. Of course, that leaves out the two biggest additions in McDavid and Eichel. In that case, we used NHL equivalencies of comparable players during their draft years and looked at their WAR in their rookie season.

Buffalo improved to the tune of almost five extra wins, while Edmonton did half of that. It’s lower than the average for the other terrible teams mentioned above, but it’s important to understand the limitations of the method of projection here. It doesn’t consider prospects like

Leon Draisaitl or

Sam Reinhart graduating to the NHL level, players already on the team that will improve naturally as they move into their prime or the improvement that will come with playing alongside better players. Call this one a conservative estimate, one that leaves Edmonton and Buffalo toiling away in the basement for another season. There is one last thing to consider, and that’s the fact that both teams drafted very special players in McDavid and Eichel. Perhaps it’s unfair to compare the Oilers and Sabres to other sad-sacks and only look at how teams fared after adding their own generational talent.

Again, the trend is crystal clear. Year One will likely still be painful, with the three teams that actually drafted the players all producing forgettable seasons in the -60 range. But the rise is quick after that and the teams will likely be contenders by the third season if history is any indication. It may take time, but the teams will be very good, very soon with a decent chance of Stanley Cups, too. It’s just not going to happen overnight.

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The Hockey News



World Junior Roundup: Sweden Crushes Austria, Slovakia Scores Important Win

Sweden had no issue handling Austria, while Slovakia got the extra point in a big contest against Latvia on a quieter day at the World Junior Championship.

Ivan Fedotov

Screen Shots: Vegas' Goalie Problem, Hockey Quebec and Flyers Prospects Stuck in Russia

Adam Proteau returns with Screen Shots to talk about where the Vegas Golden Knights go now to address their goalie situation, Hockey Quebec's investigation into racism accusations and the latest surrounding two Flyers prospects in Russia.

Colorado Avalanche

NHL Hot Seat Radar: Colorado Avalanche

There's always pressure to repeat as champions in the NHL, but the Colorado Avalanche will have to do it with a shakeup in the crease.