Skip to main content

Best puck-handling goalies

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

The importance of a good puck-handling goalie hasn’t been as big a part of the NHL for the past few years, but it has its roots as far back as Jacques Plante, who would occasionally roam well out of his crease. But comparing the goalies of today to those of yesteryear is like night and day.

Today, the style is practiced and perfected, but in the time of Gerry Cheevers, Ed Giacomin and Gary ‘Suitcase’ Smith, it was much more improvised. However, those ‘tenders still deserve recognition for starring in their time.

Smith inspired the NHL to create a rule restricting goalies from crossing the center red line after he carried the puck up ice. Giacomin is recognized by Glenn ‘Chico’ Resch and John Davidson as being the first to truly incorporate roving into his game, while Cheevers – who played a little forward in junior – is also considered among the best of his era.

Ron Hextall and Tom Barrasso bridged the gap from pioneers to perfectionists; Hextall became the first goalie to score a goal, both in the regular season and post-season. Modern goalies became so effective, the league introduced the trapezoid area behind the net in 2005-06 where goalies aren’t allowed to play the puck.

So, as we’re working away on our annual goalie issue, we decided it was a good time for the Top 10 to countdown the best puck-handling goalies of all-time.

10. Jacques Plante

Father of the mask known to wander.

9. Gerry Cheevers

Played forward for a season in junior.

8. Ed Giacomin

First goalie to record two assists in a game – and he hit a post.

7. Gary Smith

He’s the reason why goalies can’t pass the red line.

6. Ed Belfour

Now always pretty, but usually effective.

5. Tom Barrasso

Good enough for Scotty Bowman to draft him No. 5 overall.

4. Rick DiPietro

Gradual development partially forgiven by effectiveness with the puck.

3. Marty Turco

Ability to go from glove to stick to pass is impeccable.

2. Ron Hextall

First goalie to shoot the puck and score a goal.

1. Martin Brodeur

Head and shoulders better than his generation, inspired followers.

The Top 10 appears Wednesdays only on

If you enjoy this feature, subscribe to The Hockey News magazine for the exclusive countdown, Starting From 5, and other great features from the world of hockey.


Red Dutton and Eddie Shore

From the Archives: How the Amerks Almost Ruled New York

The New York Americans came before the Rangers, but the newer New York team had the success. Stan Fischler looks at the attempts to improve the Amerks.

Connor Bedard

Bedard and Friends Enjoy Homecoming at CHL/NHL Top Prospects Game

British Columbia is well represented at the 2023 CHL/NHL Top Prospects Game, including people who played with and against Connor Bedard growing up.

Rick Rypien

Hockey World and Beyond Remembers Importance of Mental Health

Adam Proteau remembers those we lost to mental illness, the supports to help those currently struggling and how there can be more strides to improve help.