• Powered by Roundtable
    Caleb Kerney
    Caleb Kerney
    Jun 25, 2023, 14:08

    Here are two outlandish Edmonton Oilers trade proposals that could land them elite defender Erik Karlsson.

    Here are two outlandish Edmonton Oilers trade proposals that could land them elite defender Erik Karlsson.

    The Edmonton Oilers are on a mission to upgrade their top-4 defence. They are looking for a way to extend Evan Bouchard and (if they can) bring in an upgrade on Cody Ceci. But what if they go a different route? What if they bring in a defenceman in the middle of a resurgence? 

    Related: 3 Crazy Oilers' Trade Proposals for Vezina Winner Hellebuyck

    Erik Karlsson just became the sixth NHL defenceman of all time to hit 100 points in a season. Karlsson is no stranger to scoring a lot of points as he has routinely been a 60-80 point defenceman. Bouchard has a high offensive ceiling, but is it Karlsson-high?

    Image

    Let's look at a few completely outlandish trade proposals the Oilers could table to the San Jose Sharks to acquire. Please note: this is all pure speculation and not based on any rumors or insider information. 

    Evan Bouchard and Darnell Nurse for Erik Karlsson

    Bouchard is still waiting for a new contract, one that should pay him quite a bit. The Oilers are likely to offer him a bridge deal because of cap constraints. That creates circumstances that make a trade even more likely, because of the opportunity that presents Bouchard to play on the best power play in the NHL and record at least 50 points. 

    Related: Oilers' Nurse Silently Had His Best Offensive Year Ever

    Darnell Nurse has a $9.25-million cap hit, Karlsson has a $11.5-million cap hit. If the Sharks retain at least $2-million in salary then the Oilers save a couple hundred thousand dollars. The Sharks get an offensive defender who can play point on their power play, and the Oilers get a dynamic Norris-Trophy-winning player in Karlsson. With Nurse being a part of the Oilers core group, it's hard to imagine a deal like this making it past the finish line.

    Jack Campbell, Evan Bouchard, Kailer Yamamoto & 1st round 2024 pick for Erik Karlsson

    The Oilers signed Jack Campbell to a five-year contract worth a $5-million cap hit last off-season. Kailer Yamamoto is a young forward still budding with potential who could make a big splash with a new team. Bouchard is a 40-point defender with an even higher offensive ceiling. This would no doubt be an appealing package for the sharks. They get a good goaltender, a young forward and a fantastic defenceman who is dangerous on the power play.

    Image

    But again, there is no way that the Oilers do this. It would not look great on the organization to trade a goalie one year removed from signing them long term. Yamamoto is the most likely to be traded of this proposed package, but even he isn't a sure thing to be moved. The Oilers also really like Bouchard.

    Related: Oilers' Pursuing Shut Down Defender Pesce

    Acquiring a talent like Karlsson might have to remain as speculation and not reality. The Oilers don't have the resources to make this happen, without also creating a hole on their roster that a prospect or inexpensive contract could fill.