Are pre-season games worth it? That's the question on every Montreal Canadiens' fan mind in the wake of Patrik Laine's injury.
Are pre-season games worth it? That's the question on every Montreal Canadiens' fan mind in the wake of Patrik Laine's injury.
Speaking to the media on Friday morning, new Montreal Canadiens forward Patrik Laine was asked if he would like to play the [then] remaining three pre-season games, and he replied:
Yeah I think so, I think we've had good conversations with the coaches, kind of what they're looking for and what I want to do. I would probably prefer to play all the games left since we don't have any back-to-backs or anything. Just trying to get as many games under my belt as I can. You can't replicate a game in practice, so try to get in game action as much as I can before the opener.
After what transpired last night, it's now obvious it won't happen. Whichever way you look at it and however optimistic you want to be about a possible prognostic, a knee-to-knee hit like the one we saw on Saturday night always comes with a stay on the injury list.
After missing so much time due to injury and personal issues, it's understandable that Laine wants as many opportunities as possible to shake off the rust and get his marks back, but hockey is a high-speed contact sport. Whenever you step on the ice, you run the risk of hurting yourself.
A Necessary Evil?
Is it worth running that risk for meaningless pre-season exhibition contests? No, probably not. There has to be a better way. All too often, injuries sustained by NHL players in the pre-season come from AHL players hoping to leave their calling cards. That should not happen.
While Laine is right that you can't replicate game action in practice, you can hold scrimmages. A career AHLer who attends his organization's training camp knows he has nothing to gain by injuring their team's star. If anything is in scrimmage, they are forced to hold back on the rough stuff and show how they can actually play hockey.
Of course, scrimmages involving fringe NHLers and AHL journeymen will never offer the same caliber of hockey as a proper NHL game and, therefore, won't allow the most talented players to get proper reps, but that could still be done.
Possible Solutions?
If the pre-season game requirements were changed in the next collective bargaining agreement and the definition of "veteran" was reviewed, there could be a safer environment for NHL stars to shine in. One X user suggests perhaps the A version of a team should always just play the A version of its opponent, and the B versions should play each other.
How would we then know if a player is ready to make the jump from the junior leagues or the AHL to the NHL? Well, perhaps the team should be allowed to keep their best prospects with the team longer than they are now. Give those guys auditions in regular season games and make the entry-level slide conditions different. Instead of being a maximum of nine games before sending them down, make it 15. I know this only applies to a small minority of 18-19-year-old players, but I believe it would help, and I'm not alone.
You don't need to audition career minor leaguers whose biggest skills are grit and physicality; you know what they bring to the table. Seeing them in action against other AHLers is enough to assess their strengths and weaknesses.
The players who show promise during camp could then be given their shot in real game action once everyone is actually on the ice to win and not to make a name for themselves as enforcers.
What's Next?
While what happened to Laine is beyond unfortunate, he's not the first NHL player to suffer a serious injury in the pre-season, and the rules have never been changed because of that, but that doesn't mean they should never be.
The current CBA will run until the end of the 2025-26 season; now is the time to consider what needs to be changed and/or improved. If I run the show, the way the pre-season works is at the top of my list, closely followed by the salary cap loophole that plagues the playoffs and essentially amounts to circumventing the rules. Loopholes are meant to be fixed, there's a reason why laws can be amended, because people find their way around them and a CBA is no different.
Related
Patrik Laine Speaks With Members of the Montreal Media Following Trade to the Canadiens
Canadiens: GM Kent Hughes Discusses Laine Trade Acquisition
Canadiens: About the Harris-Laine Trade
Follow Karine on X @KarineHains Bluesky @karinehains.bsky.social and Threads @karinehains
Bookmark The Hockey News Canadiens' page for all the news and happenings around the Canadiens