Powered by Roundtable

Can the New York Islanders "Identity Line" still be a factor in 2023-24? "The Maven" Stan Fischler shares his thoughts.

Fischler on Tonelli Becoming an Islander

What is there to say about the New York Islanders seemingly inseparable Fourth Line?

Or, to put it more practically, what can the Matt Martin--Casey Cizikas--Cal Clutterbuck trio do for the Islanders in 2023-24?

This is a vexing question since the unit -- affectionately known as "The Identity Line" -- is not exactly overloaded with youth; and just may be missing its identity.

Entering the new season, Cal will be 35, Casey, 32, and Double M 34. They've been together for eight of the past ten seasons. At their best, they provide energy and do time-and-a-half killing penalties.

The good news is that singly and united, they did steer the Nassaumen to a playoff berth while eight other outfits were behind the NHL 8-Ball.

The bad news was that their overall offensive production left something -- like more goals -- to be desired.

As a matter of fact, more than a few media types expected the 2022-23 season to spell Sayonara for the threesome.

Yet many of us -- The Maven included -- sang a sincere song in their honor; "Just One More Chance."

Islanders general manager Lou Lamoriello seconded the motion during his last State Of The Team address, and what Lou says readily can be interpreted as his stamp of approval.

Analyzing the line, player by player, one likely is to conclude that yes, another season together just might be a darn good idea, and here's why:

1. They read each other like a best-selling new novel.
2. Their camaraderie is contagious and retains a "family" feel among the Nassaumen.
3. One last comeback season is not out of the question for over 30 NHLers.
4. Because of the above statement, their motivation will be meteoric.

That. of course, does not mean that coach Lane Lambert will be as locked into the idea of retaining the unit should it falter. (After all, he does like his job.

But The Maven has faith in the Identity Line's identity.

Cizikas hasn't lost his scoring touch. Clutterbuck remains one of the NHL's most savvy performers.

Martin's passion -- sometimes misplaced, as we noted in the Canes playoff -- has Islanders written all over it.

Frankly, I believe that retaining the Identity Line is the right thing to do.

Any objections?

Yes!

Well, Judge Maven has one thing to say.

"OVER-RULED!"