John Tavares picked up a major win in his tax dispute against the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) on Friday. His appeal case in the Tax Court of Canada saw his team win their motion, which compelled the CRA to answer questions related to how Tavares' audit was handled.

While it's not a win in the sense of a judgment of his appeal, the case is paused until a trial date is set, which Tavares' lawyers are trying to establish.

Last week, the Court ordered the CRA to disclose key internal records and notes related to its reassessment of Tavares’ $15.25 million signing bonus from 2018 after initially denying to answer questions from the appellant about how the findings in Tavares' audit and comparables were used. The CRA cited privacy concerns in answering the questions, but was compelled by a judge to respond, with limitations.

CRA Compelled To Disclose Key Audit Documents In Maple Leafs' John Tavares Tax Dispute The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has been ordered by the Tax Court of Canada to disclose key internal documents in its ongoing battle with Toronto Maple Leafs forward John Tavares, marking a significant development in a case that could have sweeping implications for how professional athletes are taxed in Canada.

At issue was whether Tavares owed approximately $8 million in Canadian taxes on the bonus. The Tavares camp argued the payment qualifies for a preferential 15% tax rate under the Canada-U.S. Tax Treaty, which covers income earned by non-residents providing services in Canada. The CRA contended that the bonus is fully taxable under Canadian law and should be treated as salary. 

The case drew a lot of interest in the sports world as professional athletes in Canada, from hockey to baseball and basketball, drew the ire of the CRA in several reassessment cases, many of which are still ongoing.

The Impact Of John Tavares' CRA Case On Canadian NHL Teams And Taxes The outcome of the dispute between the Maple Leafs' John Tavares and the Canada Revenue Agency could impact the ability of Canadian NHL teams to lure talent north of the border.

The CRA recently lost their tax court battle against former Toronto Blue Jays Josh Donaldson and Russell Martin over RCAs (Retirement Compensation Agreement), but have since filed an appeal in federal court.

In Tavares' case, a win would result could help Canadian teams in their recruiting efforts as they compete against franchises from United States, particularly those from states that are taxed at a lower rate.

Tavares just finished up a seven-year, $77 million contract that expires on June 30. He is a free agent at the end of the season. 

Update: An original version of this story stated the case was indefinitely paused after the court was adjourned without a date to be set. Both sides on the case have since clarified that applies to Tavares' hearing and not the case and the case remains ongoing.

Maple Leafs Play-By-Play Commentator Joe Bowen Announces 2025-26 Season Will Be Last Behind Microphone Play-by-play commentator Joe Bowen's cemented phrase, 'Holy Mackinaw!' will only be heard around the Toronto Maple Leafs for one more season.

Report: Mitch Marner's Camp 'Has Not Engaged' With Maple Leafs Ahead Of Free Agency, Tenure In Toronto Likely Over It appears the Mitch Marner saga with the Toronto Maple Leafs could be coming to a close.