Being drafted by a team doesn't ensure you suit up for that franchise. These five players learned that the hard way, but they still went on to be stars in the NHL.
It doesn’t happen often, but every now and then, an NHL team drafts a player who never suits up for the club that selected him, only to watch that player go on to become a star elsewhere.
Plenty of players are drafted and never end up wearing the jersey of the team that called their name. But to become a legitimate star in one of the toughest leagues in the world without ever playing a game for the team that drafted you is pretty rare.
If we look at the biggest names and the best players who fall into this rare category, there’s some pretty strong talent represented. Here is the top five.
Eric Lindros, C, Quebec Nordiques
Perhaps the most famous and notorious name to never wear the sweater of the team he was drafted by, Eric Lindros will always be remembered for his refusal to wear a Quebec Nordiques jersey as much as he’ll be remembered for his on-ice dominance.
After an arbitrator awarded Lindros to the Philadelphia Flyers in one of the strangest dual trades in NHL history, Lindros went on to win the Hart Memorial Trophy (1995) and had several incredible seasons in the NHL.
The Nordiques took Lindros first overall in 1991, even though he'd made it clear beforehand that he had no intention of playing for them. The Nordiques knew how good Lindros would be and that he wouldn’t play for them. They took him regardless and made a massive trade that set them up for Stanley Cup success.
Meanwhile, Lindros went on to become one of the most dominant power forwards of his era — just never in Quebec.
Jarome Iginla, RW, Dallas Stars
Drafted by the Dallas Stars, Jarome Iginla was selected 11th overall in 1995, but Dallas traded him to the Calgary Flames before he ever played a game for the Stars.
The deal came together just over five months after Dallas drafted him, and as much as it hurt to lose Joe Nieuwendyk in the trade, Iginla spent 16 seasons in Calgary, becoming the face of the franchise, a six-time All-Star, and a future Hall of Famer.
The trade made for one of the more balanced blockbusters in NHL history, and Iginla's career in Calgary became legendary.
Adam Fox, D, Calgary Flames
Speaking of the Flames, Calgary drafted defenseman Adam Fox 66th overall in 2016, and he actually snubbed two teams before joining the New York Rangers.
Fox chose the college hockey route through Harvard. The Flames eventually traded his rights to the Carolina Hurricanes in 2018 (in a multi-player deal), and when Fox wouldn't sign there either, the Hurricanes flipped him to the Rangers in 2019, his childhood favorite team.
The Rangers received a gem.
Fox became just the second defenseman ever to win the Norris Trophy, joining Bobby Orr, in his second NHL season. His play has dropped off some since then, but he’s still considered an elite defenseman in the NHL.
Nick Suzuki, C, Vegas Golden Knights
The Vegas Golden Knights took Nick Suzuki 13th overall in 2017 and signed him to an entry-level deal that summer. However, as part of Vegas’ quest to constantly be in on every major trade conversation and grab the big name that becomes available, the Golden Knights traded Suzuki to the Montreal Canadiens alongside Tomas Tatar and a 2019 second-round pick.
Their target? Max Pacioretty.
Suzuki never played a game for the Golden Knights, but he’s played many games for Montreal. He’s one of the great young NHL talents, and his continued growth into a franchise centerpiece has made that trade one of the most lopsided in recent NHL memory.
He's since been named the 31st captain in Canadiens history, and the Canadiens are a team to watch. Suzuki also just posted his first 100-plus point season and represented Team Canada at the Olympics.
Cutter Gauthier, LW, Philadelphia Flyers
Philadelphia took Cutter Gauthier fifth overall in 2022, but after telling the team at the draft he was "built to be a Flyer," he changed his mind just months later and refused to communicate with the front office. He essentially ghosted the Flyers until they traded him. It was one of the more odd situations in recent NHL history.
The Flyers ultimately traded him to the Anaheim Ducks in January 2024 in exchange for defenseman Jamie Drysdale and a 2025 second-round pick. Now, it appears Gauthier is pulling another power play on the Ducks. With Leo Carlsson accepting an offer sheet worth $18 million per season, Gauthier is reportedly holding out and refusing to sign a $13 million-per-season deal over four years.
He believes his 41-goal season in 2025-26 is worth a huge amount of money. It’s created (along with some untimely decisions by the Ducks) a tricky salary cap situation.
Gauthier's story is still being written — his contract standoff means he could force his way out of two organizations. At least he played for the Ducks.
For action-packed issues, access to the entire magazine archive and a free issue, subscribe to The Hockey News at THN.com/free.See more of The Hockey News on Google and save us as a preferred source. Get the latest news and trending stories by subscribing to our newsletter here. And share your thoughts by commenting below the article on THN.com or creating your own post in our community forum.
