• Powered by Roundtable
    Spencer Lazary
    Nov 15, 2025, 03:58
    Updated at: Nov 15, 2025, 03:58

    With high-end talent and plenty of depth, this summer’s collection of free agents may be the best ever

    The Hockey News has released its archive to all THN subscribers: 76 years of history, stories, and features.

    Subscribe now to view the full THN Archives here

    Also, go to thn.com/free to subscribe.

     A Class of True Class - May. 29, 2019  – Ken Campbell

    LAST SUMMER, NHL TEAMS were chasing the biggest fish in the history of free agency while wearing hip waders. This summer, they’re going to have to rent a craft and hit the deeper waters. They’ll probably require a bigger net and a bigger boat.

    The summer of 2018’s UFA market was all about John Tavares, and after that – not to disparage the likes of James van Riemsdyk and Paul Stastny – the pickings were relatively slim. The summer of 2019 will have plenty of star power to be sure – including winners of the Hart, Vezina, Norris, Calder and Conn Smythe Trophies – but it also has very good depth of talent. And part of what makes it so impressive is that, unlike in previous years, there are some seriously good players who will actually make it to the open market on July 1.

    In fact, if you were putting together an all-star team of this summer’s top UFAs, you’d have a forward line of Matt Duchene between Artemi Panarin and Mats Zuccarello, a defense tandem of Erik Karlsson and Jake Gardiner and Sergei Bobrovsky in goal. We’re not sure who would actually play any defense on that unit, but there’s a good chance it wouldn’t have to, because it would have the puck all the time.

    Panarin and Bobrovsky are fully expected to hit the market and, depending on what happens with Karlsson in San Jose, will be the crown jewels of free agency. By all accounts, there have been no substantive negotiations between Karlsson and the Sharks, and management has done a good job respecting Karlsson’s need for time to make a decision. Both sides were waiting until the end of the Sharks’ season to start delving more deeply into talks, but as July 1 approaches, the time will be nigh.

    Down the middle, there’s some high quality with Duchene and Joe Pavelski. Part of the rationale for the Columbus Blue Jackets acquiring Duchene at the trade deadline was that it gave them an opportunity to have him in the lineup and the city for a good period of time so he could have a chance to experience the lifestyle and get a feel for the organization. Suddenly, what once looked like a slam dunk to Nashville, where Duchene would be able to feed his love for country music, doesn’t seem quite as certain. As far as Pavelski is concerned, it feels like he’s a lifetime Shark, but the organization may, for cap reasons, be forced to choose between him and Karlsson. Complicating matters even more is the fact that, at the age of 34, Pavelski potted 38 goals and continues to be a consistently productive 60-plus point player. As far as goals go, the highest in that department is Jeff Skinner, who scored 40 goals for the Buffalo Sabres but faded badly down the stretch with just four in his final 25 games.

    UNLIKE PAST YEARS, THERE ARE SOME SERIOUSLY GOOD PLAYERS WHO WILL HIT THE OPEN MARKET

    If there is a chink in the armor among this group, it is probably on the blueline. Yes, there is Karlsson, but even with him there are concerns about his long-term health and effectiveness because of his reconstructed ankle. After that, Gardiner was much maligned in Toronto for his defensive play but is a premier point-producer who has the feel of a player who could really flourish in a market where the scrutiny is not so white-hot. Tyler Myers is long removed from his Calder Trophy halcyon days, but he’s a large presence who still has the capacity to eat minutes and play in the top-four. Alexander Edler and the Vancouver Canucks seem tied to each other.

    But where this class has real value is in its depth. Who would not want a player such as Zuccarello among its forwards, particularly after he shared the team lead in playoff points for the Dallas Stars with 11, including four goals, in 13 games? Or Jordan Eberle, who led the surprising New York Islanders in playoff points? Speaking of the Islanders, Anders Lee and Brock Nelson can be counted on for goal totals in the mid-20s.

    Between the pipes, there’s Bobrovsky, but there’s also Semyon Varlamov, who lost his starting job to Philipp Grubauer but is only a year removed from posting a .920 save percentage and might benefit from a change of scenery.

    Aside from the Blue Jackets, the Sharks stand to lose the most from this year’s UFA class with Pavelski, Karlsson, Joe Thornton, Gustav Nyquist and Joonas Donskoi all potentially available. It all makes for arguably the most intriguing July 1 signing day and summer we’ve seen in free agency.

    Let us know what you think below.

    Stay updated with the most interesting Sharks stories, analysis, breaking news, and more!

    Image

    For action-packed issues, access to the entire magazine archive and a free issue, subscribe to The Hockey News at THN.com/free. Get the latest news and trending stories by subscribing to our newsletter here. And share your thoughts by commenting below the article on THN.com or creating your own post in our community forum. 

    From THN's Archive: Riding Shotgun From THN's Archive: Riding Shotgun Players who have the good fortune to play with Joe Thornton watch their numbers rise – just ask Jonathan Cheechoo Sharks' Skinner Needs Further Evaluation To Determine Extent Of Injury Sharks' Skinner Needs Further Evaluation To Determine Extent Of Injury Skinner's lower-body injury sustained against Calgary casts doubt on his return. The Sharks await further evaluation to assess the full extent of the damage. From THN's Archive: Big Joe Rarin' To Go From THN's Archive: Big Joe Rarin' To Go In honour of Jumbo Joe getting inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame this past week. Here is an archive from The Hockey News about his time with the San Jose Sharks.